First I rave about Portugal today, then Tunisia, and now...China...
China?!! A country of which I am so often so critical, especially with regard to its usually poor record on animal rights and environmental issues? That China? Yes, that China.
And it gets better.
Below is an open letter in full that my mom forwarded to me - she was completely over the moon at the prospect of Chinese citizens showing their enlightenment on an animal rights issue!
The letter is from concerned Chinese citizens to the Fisheries Minister of...wait for it...Canada!
Yes, that Canada - once a nation with a (relatively) proud environmental record, and now fast becoming the World's Environmental Hypocrite of note.
Chinese citizens catigating Canada for trying to import seal products into China...
China showing up Canada for the latter's abominable animal rights abuses regarding the annual (and totally sickening) harp seal slaughter...
China sticking it to Canada on animal rights...
You gotta love it...
****************************************************************************
2011年1月12日 北京
An Open Letter to Gail Shea, Canada’s Fisheries Minister
Minister Shea:We are animal loving citizens from across China. We are in the millions in number and are growing by day. Care for the weak, love of life, and striving for the harmony between humans and nature are the unstopped trend of the contemporary time. Living in this era, we feel proud to follow this trend. Yet, your arrival in China and the Canadian delegation you are leading, the second of its kind since last year, for promoting Canadian seal product sale in China, are nothing but an act hindering China’s progress in modernization and civilization. “Do not give others what you yourself do not want” is an ancient Chinese saying. Known to all, Canadian seal products are made out of the blood and flesh of the seal pups and out of the blood and tears of the mother seals. The cruelty of seal products has been condemned by the majority of Canadians and others in Europe and the Americas. How can you peddle this shameful product to China? You have come to China two years in a row to promote the morally repulsive products.
Do you, Minister Shea, realize what kind of wrongs you are committing?
First of all, going out of your way to promote Canadian seal products to Chinese consumers is indicative of your position supporting the racist and cultural imperialistic bias towards the Chinese people held by the sealing industry. The perceptions that “Chinese eat everything” and that Chinese care nothing about animal suffering show how outdated the Canadian sealing industry’s view of the Chinese people is, a view that is reminiscent of the prejudice against non-Western people and non-Western culture held by the West when it was brutalizing the non-Western world in the old days. China has a legacy of compassion for all living creatures. Progress in animal protection in the contemporary era has also been recognized. Based on what can the Canadian sealing industry claim that the Chinese nation is indifferent to animal suffering? Minister Shea, what makes you the advocate of seal product sale in China, products that are hugely controversial and morally indefensible?
Second, the view that Chinese consumers will embrace products of animal cruelty indicates Canada’s complete out-of-touch with reality in China. The world is watching every new development in China in order to be on the same page with China’s breathtaking transformation. Refusing to face reality in China is a sign of arrogance on the part of the Canadian government. Since China initiated its economic reform program, the public environmental protection awareness has been rising. More and more consumers are consuming with a view to protect environment and the ecosystem. The Canadian government and sealing industry, by attempting to dump the seal products on the Chinese markets, show little respect to the Chinese consumers.
Third, by promoting seal products in China, Shea is destroying the good image Canada has long enjoyed in China. Canada is one of the first Western nations that extended diplomatic recognition to the People’s Republic of China. Dr. Norman Beethune, a Canadian surgeon who worked in China during the Second World War, was a hero to the Chinese people. Mark Roswell, a Canadian student-turned comedian, is a celebrity in China. Both gentlemen have helped shorten the distance between China and Canada. Canadian sealing industry is undoing in China what Dr. Beethune and Mr. Roswell have accomplished. You only need to access China’s biggest online portal (http://news.qq.com/photon/tpyk/haibao.htm) and read the more than 16,000 readers’ comments to realize how Canada’s image has been tarnished because of Canadian brutality against baby seals.
Fourth, to China, Canadian seal products are like the opium dumped on China by Great Britain in the early 19th century. Both seal products and opium serve to encourage irresponsible consumer behaviors. Worse still, they can poison young consumers. Opium sold to China did great damage to the bodies of the Chinese consumers. Seal products, a symbol of violence to the weak and of indifference to brutality, can distort the souls and destroy the spirit of the Chinese consumers. As a developed Western democracy, Canada should help China’s progress in civilization. It has NO right to sabotage it by dumping morally objectionable products in China.
Finally, descriptions of seal products sold in the Greater China Region are full of exaggerations and misleading information. What is the scientific basis of the claimed power of the seal oil products? Some seal oil products are made specifically for infants. What are the possible side-effects or consequences if the product is accidentally taken orally by the infant? What is the residue level of harmful elements in the seal oil product, a level that is harmful to health? Canada should be ready all time to take responsibilities for any health consequences incurred by Canadian seal products.Minister Shea and Canadian government, promoting seal products to China is terribly unwise, short-sighted and unworthy. Seal products brutalize defenseless seal pups, sabotage China’s modernization (in moral development), poison and harm Chinese consumers, and tarnish Canadian international image. Dumping the unwanted seal products harms China without even benefiting Canada.
Does Canada want to repeat the mistake of opium dumping Great Britain?
Animal loving citizens of China
*******************************************************************
Priceless letter, brilliantly written and ironic to the hilt...just the dig at the British empire and its outrageous 19th-century opium campaign to destabilize China is worth the read.
China may continue to have an appalling record in some areas of animal rights and environmental justice, no doubt - but this letter as an example of changes within Chinese society can only bode well for the future enlightenment about animals and the environment in that country.
It's frankly what Canada deserves...
And all power to the rising number of Chinese animal-loving citizens who don't wish their country to be synonymous any more with being notorious for horrific animal abuse.
Do you get my point?
No comments:
Post a Comment